Lemon law attorneys are the experts you need to structure your case using evidence that proves your vehicle’s substantial defect (more on how that’s defined in a moment). The key to building a strong case is to put together relevant evidence from reputable sources. These sources should align with what you are experiencing, so they clearly support the exact defect claim you are making.
One source that attorneys monitor closely is the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) website. That’s because the U.S. Department of Transportation provides this federal database that tracks recalls, consumer complaints, and additional data. By tracking data that aligns with their cases and using it to support vehicle owner documentation and expert witness testimony, attorneys can have the best opportunity to win lemon law claims.
What types of data do lemon law attorneys discover on the NHTSA website, and how do they make use of this data? With the thousands of records added to the site regularly, how can lemon law lawyers sift through it to find the exact supporting evidence they need to pursue compensation on behalf of clients?
We’ll review the answers to these questions and how those play into the benefits you receive by working with a lemon law attorney to gain just compensation for your defective vehicle. Before we delve into the NHTSA website discussion, it will help to know what criteria are used by the state to qualify your vehicle as a lemon. Then, we’ll see how NHTSA site data can help your attorney pursue either a buyback or replacement vehicle from the manufacturer on your behalf.
How a Vehicle Qualifies as a Lemon: Defining a Substantial Defect Under State Law
A substantial defect defined under state lemon law doesn’t include every type of defect. It specifically is one that severely impacts the use, value, or safety of a vehicle. It remains unfixable across the state’s allotted number of repair attempts (usually 3–4). If the vehicle has remained out of service for a defined total number of days due to warranty defects (often at least 30 days within the first 12-24 months), that is another criterion that can qualify your vehicle as a lemon. You don’t have to satisfy both the ‘days out of service’ and ‘unfixable across allotted repair attempts’ criteria. You only have to satisfy one or the other. Your attorney will also review your state’s specific reporting timeframes as they apply to your claim.
If your vehicle is deemed a lemon, in some states, the manufacturer receives a final attempt at a repair after it is notified of the claim. If it cannot or will not repair the vehicle, your lemon law attorney can move forward with the case.
For more information on arbitration and other frequently asked lemon law questions, click here.
What is the NHTSA Website?
Once your vehicle is classified as a lemon, your lemon law attorney will begin the process of gathering evidence and structuring your case. Part of that evidence gathering will involve reviewing your warranty and all documentation you have (correspondence with the dealer and manufacturer, photos, videos, and repair records that demonstrate the defect’s presence). The attorney will also dig into the NHTSA website. As we mentioned, this database offers data on complaints, recalls, investigations, and more. The attorney can use this data to establish that a vehicle model has a widespread, inherent defect versus an issue only affecting your car.
Types of Information that Can be Found in NHTSA Searches
Lemon law attorneys can, and do, go through the NHTSA website by hand if they choose. Often, the monitoring of this site is done via sophisticated software and site crawler tools. These online tools look for specific complaints, investigations, and recalls. They also look for something called Technical Service Bulletins (TSBs). These are internal communications between manufacturers and dealers regarding known issues and the recommended diagnostic and repair procedures that the manufacturers want the dealers to follow.
So, for example, if you have a Cadillac Escalade with a specific steering issue, the attorney will attempt to find NHTSA data that shows that your car isn’t the only one having this problem. If data is present on the NHTSA site that confirms the substantial defect your vehicle is experiencing, the attorney will incorporate this evidence into your claim.
Image Source: Pexels
How Consumers Can Use NHTSA Data
Attorneys aren’t the only ones who can use the NHTSA website to check for recall, complaint, and investigation data. Consumers can enter their own information there, plus review others’ complaints. For example, you can view (and download if you choose) all the complaint data for a particular vehicle. Enter your car’s year, make, and model. Several data headings come up. Click on the number under ‘Complaints’ to go directly to the listings of each complaint. Select a particular individual complaint you want to read, and it expands to a full report from the consumer. Here’s a simulated consumer data entry: ‘I was driving through the city when my truck’s brakes locked and I couldn’t stop.’ If you want to save a particular complaint without having to visit the NHTSA site again, they provide a link to it that you can bookmark.
Comparing vehicles’ safety ratings is another feature on the NHTSA website. Click the ‘Ratings’ heading and enter your vehicle’s year, make, and model. Say, for example, you want to compare various types of 2026 Ford F-150 trucks. Enter ‘2026 Ford F-150,’ and the variety of models of these trucks comes up on the screen. You can compare two models, and the site provides safety data for each. When you scroll down the comparison results page, it will tell you what safety issues, recalls, TSBs, and investigations are listed for these vehicles.
You may also be interested in the NHTSA’s publications that include various crash data and traffic safety facts. All this data can be used not only after you have problems with your vehicle but also proactively to help you minimize the risk of buying a lemon car or truck.
Proving the Substantial Defect Using NHTSA and Additional Evidence
NHTSA data is one form of evidence, even if it does support your claim. A skilled lemon law attorney builds a solid case to stand up to manufacturer challenges. That means that every form of evidence that strengthens the claim will be used by the attorney to prove the substantial defect. As we discussed, it will be important for the lemon law lawyer to receive all the evidence you have about the defect. Don’t worry if you may have some gaps in your documentation; the attorney can obtain various records regarding repair attempts or other communications. In addition to your documentation, your attorney can present expert testimony from an automotive specialist, who can review your vehicle’s data logs and other information to help verify your claim.
Lemon laws are confusing. Read our guide to the lemon law complaint process.
The Benefits of Working with a Lemon Law Attorney
We’ve reviewed how an attorney establishes if a vehicle is a lemon, and the multiple forms of evidence they can use to help build a case, including NHTSA data. Another key benefit you’ll receive through working with your lemon law attorney is their negotiation skills. Most lemon law cases don’t go to court; they’re settled. You have the best opportunity for a favorable settlement with the manufacturer if your claim is backed by strong evidence, then negotiated expertly by a top attorney.
Your attorney knows the tactics the manufacturer may use to try and avoid or minimize your claim. The manufacturer may offer you a quick deal, which may be worth far less than you could get if you had the attorney negotiate for you. You might also get blamed by the manufacturer for the defect. They might say through some form of negligence that you are responsible for the vehicle’s problem. A skilled lemon law attorney fights for your rights and focuses on proving the substantial defect so you gain the compensation you are entitled to.
Contact Allen Stewart, P.C. for Expert Lemon Law Representation
Building a strong lemon law case requires solid evidence to support it. Allen Stewart, P.C. has won many cases by using well-structured evidence, including that found on the NHTSA website. Our lemon law lawyers are recognized as top attorneys in California, Texas, New York, and throughout the nation. Our aggressive representation can provide you with the best opportunity to stand up to the manufacturer and gain compensation.
Even with all we’ve discussed here, you may still wonder… I would like to have a good lemon law attorney, but can I afford it? It is vital that you have our top attorneys represent you, as the manufacturer will most certainly defend its interests with its legal team. You do not have to pay us to represent you. The manufacturer is obligated to pay your legal fees when you win your case.
Don’t wait to contact us. Time is of the essence with lemon law claims. Take advantage of our free consultation. Call Allen Stewart, P.C. now (866-440-2460) or schedule your free consultation online.