Allen Stewart PC

Does Lemon Law Still Apply After Your Warranty Expires?

Mechanic inspecting a car's underside in a workshop for repairs.

Image Source: Pexels

The old saying ‘timing is everything’ is one that can apply to lemon law claims. Your vehicle may be experiencing problems right now, and if your warranty is expired, you’ll likely wonder if you have any recourse against the manufacturer. As we will discuss, when the vehicle first began having problems is a key consideration for how and if you can gain compensation.

So what happens; does lemon law still cover you when the original manufacturer’s warranty is expired?

The short answer is yes, it can, but it greatly depends on timing. Pursuing a lemon law claim after your warranty has expired means you’ll need to pinpoint when the issue first began.

Before we get into specific warranty expiration details, we will explore the crux of all state lemon laws (even though states do add their own facets, such as in some states, they may cover used cars). The main factor in lemon law claims is if the vehicle is exhibiting a substantial defect, which is specifically defined under lemon law.

The Lemon Law Definition of a Substantial Defect

To qualify as a lemon, a substantial defect that is unfixable must be present, severely impacting your vehicle’s use, value, or safety. The vehicle must exhibit this defect that is unrepairable across the number of state-allotted repair attempts (usually 3-4 repair attempts are provided by states to manufacturers, although this number can vary by state).

Your vehicle may also qualify as a lemon via the ‘days out of service’ rule. That applies when a vehicle has been out of service due to substantial under-warranty defects. The timeframe for this is usually a set number of days (often at least 30 days within the first 12-24 months).

Note: You only need to meet one of the above criteria; you don’t have to satisfy the allotted number of repairs and days out of service.

If your vehicle qualifies as a lemon, the attorney will notify the manufacturer regarding your claim. In some states, the manufacturer gets one final opportunity to fix the vehicle. If the manufacturer cannot or will not fix it, your lawyer can pursue the case

For more information on arbitration and other frequently asked Breach of Warranty questions, click here.

What Compensation Can You Win?

It Depends on When the Defect Began

The best opportunity to gain a buyback or replacement vehicle is if your car or truck’s defect first occurred while your vehicle was under the original manufacturer’s warranty period. If you took it to an authorized dealer while it was covered under warranty, your lemon law rights are much clearer. Even if the issue persists after the original manufacturer’s warranty expires, the fact that you took the vehicle in to the dealer when the car was covered, is what locks in your lemon law protection. This is true because the law concludes that the manufacturer didn’t satisfy its obligation to fix the vehicle. It got a fair chance to attempt to resolve the problem during the warranty coverage window.

Standard lemon laws won’t apply if your vehicle’s defect manifested after the warranty coverage period. One point that may come up is ‘manifestation,’ where, let’s say, you noticed a problem with the vehicle the third year you owned it. You didn’t take it in to the dealer for a repair attempt until the fourth year of ownership (after your warranty had just expired). Not having any repair attempt records for year three (while your car was still covered by the warranty) makes it much harder to prove when the issue actually began, weakening a potential lemon law claim.

Why You Need a Lemon Law Attorney

Even if your vehicle appears to qualify as a lemon, you might think you have no chance against the manufacturer with your claim. Fortunately, you can get the representation you need to pursue compensation without worrying about cost.

Fee Shifting Allows You to Afford Lemon Law Representation

Some vehicle owners think that they can’t access representation from a lemon law lawyer due to it costing too much. Under state lemon laws, a consumer-friendly rule called “fee-shifting” ensures you can afford legal help. The manufacturer is obligated to pay your legal fees when you win your case. Plus, lemon law attorneys often provide free consultations (866-440-2460). You can show your evidence to the attorney and have them determine if your claim is valid. If so, then the lawyer can tell you about the next steps involved in them representing you against the manufacturer.

The Benefit of a Lemon Law Attorney’s Negotiation Skills

Since most lemon law cases are settled out of court, the advantage you have with a skilled lemon law attorney representing you is substantial. They will put you in the best position to receive the buyback or replacement vehicle you deserve for compensation. Through the lawyer’s careful structuring of the case, they will work to prove the existence of the substantial vehicle defect. The lawyer will build the case via your evidence (photos, correspondence with the dealer, and repair orders); testimony from vehicle experts; and supporting evidence from online databases. The goal is to hold the manufacturer accountable for breaching its promise (the warranty) of a car that works as it should.

Lemon laws are confusing. Read our guide to the lemon law complaint process.

What Protections Do You Have Under the Federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act?

What if your attorney determines that your state’s lemon law will not offer the pathway you need to pursue compensation for your defective vehicle? The federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act offers potential advantages for consumers dealing with a post-warranty lemon dispute:

Specifically, the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act offers these protections:

The Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act makes manufacturers designate any warranties they offer as either “full” or “limited” and specify exactly what they cover in a single, clear, easy-to-read document. They must also make the warranty conspicuously available for consumer review, allowing consumers to shop for warranty coverage before making a purchase.

The Act also prohibits these companies from disclaiming or modifying implied warranties with their written ones. This means consumers are always entitled to the basic protections of “implied warranties of merchantability”—that a good sold must do what that good is supposed to. For example, a new car should operate and convey passengers and cargo from one place to another safely. A car that cannot do this does not conform to the implied warranty of merchantability.

Contact Allen Stewart, P.C. for Expert Lemon Law Representation

You don’t have to take on the manufacturer by yourself; Allen Stewart, P.C. has won many lemon law cases across the country. We fight aggressively for our clients’ rights and anticipate and counter manufacturer challenges to your claim. Manufacturers may try to give you a lowball offer, deny your claim, or even blame you for causing your vehicle’s defect. Our attorneys are well-known in California, New York, Texas, and throughout the nation for their ability to hold manufacturers accountable so clients can win the compensation they deserve.

Maybe you’re wondering if you need a lawyer. Be assured that the manufacturer will certainly use its legal team to protect its interests. You need our top lemon law lawyers fighting for your rights. Remember, you do not have to pay us to represent you. Plus, our initial consultation is free, so there is no barrier to you pursuing your valid lemon law claim.

Don’t wait to contact us. Call Allen Stewart, P.C. now (866-440-2460) and schedule your free consultation. Even if you’re not sure if your car qualifies as a lemon, that is what our attorneys specialize in; have them determine this for you. Call Allen Stewart, P.C. today (866-440-2460) or schedule your free case review online.

This information brought to you by Allen Stewart P.C.

Exit mobile version