We handle cases across the United States. Allen Stewart is licensed to practice law in Texas, California, New York, Pennsylvania, Missouri, North Carolina, Ohio and Arizona.
Understanding Tesla Lemon Law

If you have encountered a persistent, significant issue with your Tesla vehicle and are considering pursuing a Tesla buyback, you may have several questions. A primary concern might be: “What level of severity must my vehicle’s issue reach to qualify for the Tesla Buyback Program?” Additionally, you will likely require guidance on Tesla Lemon Law to navigate the process from addressing your vehicle’s malfunction to securing either a replacement or a refund. Here, we’ll review potential Tesla issues that can result in buyback claims, and also how your Tesla lemon law attorney can assist with pursuing compensation.
The Public’s Fascination with Tesla Vehicles
People like Tesla vehicles for many reasons, including the futuristic look. These vehicles’ advanced technology and exceptional driving experience are often remarked on by owners, with numerous comments citing how much they love the innovation. Many say they’re the best cars they’ve ridden in or driven due to the quiet electric motor, instant torque, and responsive handling.
Eco-conscious buyers are drawn to electric Tesla vehicles. Cost-wise, Teslas are pricier than average cars but competitive within the luxury segment, with relatively affordable price points for the high-tech performance the vehicles deliver.
For more information on arbitration and other frequently asked lemon law questions, click here
Reported Tesla Problems
Even with the stellar reputation Tesla has for its innovative technology, there have been some serious issues across Tesla models, causing owners to pursue Tesla lemon law claims.
Tesla owners pursue lemon law claims for these and a variety of other reasons. Each model has had notable defects reported, including these key problems that could lead to Tesla buybacks:
- Battery Issues: Battery degradation or failure to hold a charge can seriously impact vehicle range and reliability, which may require costly replacements. This issue is periodically reported across Model S, Model 3, and Model X, often leading to service delays.
- Suspension Concerns: Uneven handling can be a safety concern, and can be caused by failed control arms or bushings. This has been noted in Model S and Model 3, with some owners reporting premature wear.
- Window Glass Issues: Safety can be impacted by defective window glass, such as spontaneous cracking or poor sealing leading to leaks; these have been reported with Model 3 and Model X.
- Defects Causing Overheating or Power Loss: Serious drivability issues have been reported due to overheating components or sudden power loss. This affects Model S and Model X, with some cases linked to thermal management failures.
- Door Handles: Malfunctioning door handles, particularly those that fail to extend or retract, have frustrated owners by making it difficult to access the vehicle. This issue primarily affects the Tesla Model S, with some reports also in early Model X vehicles.
- Paint: Some Tesla owners have noted substandard finishes from the factory. Poor paint quality, including chipping, peeling, or uneven application, has been a persistent complaint, often requiring repaints. This affects the Model S, Model 3, and early Model X.
- Auto Park Difficulties: Some Tesla owners have reported that the auto-park feature often misjudges spaces or fails to execute parking maneuvers, compromising safety. This is reported in Model S, Model 3, and Model X, particularly with early Full Self-Driving versions.
- Backup Camera Problems: Safety issues involving failed backup cameras that don’t display or show distorted images are issues that impact Model S, Model 3, and Model X, often requiring software or hardware fixes.
- Wiring and Electrical Failures: Faulty wiring or electrical issues have caused some system-wide failures. These are attributable to short circuits or malfunctioning sensors, and are reported in Model S, Model 3, and Model X.
Lemon Law Connection: These issues, plus various software problems, when unresolvable after multiple repair attempts (typically two for safety issues or four for others, per state laws), have led to Tesla lemon law claims, particularly for critical defects like battery or electrical failures, with owners seeking buybacks or replacements.
How Does Lemon Law Help You Get a Tesla Buyback?

There are rules in place to define which vehicles are covered by lemon laws, as well as timeframes and mileage constraints, within a general lemon law process. Your Tesla lemon law attorney will review your claim against your state’s lemon laws and federal law. Then, through the repair records and other documentation you provide, plus potential usage of expert testimony and other evidence, the attorney will prove that your Tesla is a candidate for a replacement vehicle or buyback.
Your attorney can assist you via this Tesla lemon law process for a buyback or other compensation:
- Organize all records to prove your claim. All documents relating to your car’s issues and how they occurred, when they occurred, and your correspondence with the dealer and Tesla can help back up your claim.
- Depending on your state’s lemon law, Tesla is allowed a certain number of repair attempts. Your attorney will advise you what the number of allowed attempts is in your state.
- Get in touch with Tesla and discuss your issues. Your Tesla lemon law attorney can initiate this for you to work with Tesla on a potential buyback. A lemon law attorney can negotiate on your behalf for the buyback or other suitable compensation.
- Arbitration can be another avenue you can pursue, should the buyback not work out with Tesla. Your attorney can represent you in these proceedings, with arbitration usually binding on the manufacturer but not you, the consumer.
- Suing Tesla in court. If arbitration does not provide a suitable remedy, your attorney can sue Tesla to fight for your right to a refund or a replacement vehicle. Please note that consumers don’t have to pay out of pocket for Tesla lemon law lawyers, so if you pursue your claim in court, it is usually true under state lemon law that the manufacturer pays your attorney fees.
Even though Tesla offers a buyback program, having an attorney on your side to build your case and prove it against the manufacturer, is vital. Your lemon law attorney will represent you in defect-related cases. That is the crux of all lemon law; proving a substantial defect. Tesla lemon law lawyers specifically represent clients in cases that are related to substantial defects that severely impact the vehicle’s use, value, or safety.
Please note: At any point in the Tesla buyback program process (pursuing your lemon law claim), your attorney can negotiate a settlement with the manufacturer. The vast majority of lemon law cases settle out of court. The skill and experience of your lemon law attorney can ensure, if there is a settlement, that you receive maximum compensation.
Allen Stewart, P.C. can leverage the federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, in addition to your state law, to get you the compensation you deserve. Call us (866-440-2460) for your free consultation, or contact us online.
Key point: Some people have heard that if they didn’t opt out of Tesla’s arbitration within 30 days of when they first bought their vehicle, they have little or no recourse in a lemon law case.
Actually, Tesla’s private arbitration program is for non-defect related issues such as delayed deliveries, unauthorized service charges, misrepresentation in the purchase contract, damage during delivery, and more.
Allen Stewart, P.C. Provides Experienced Tesla Lemon Law Representation
Everything seemed great when you bought your new Tesla. Sometimes, unfortunately, substantial defects may crop up that are impossible to fix. You don’t have to stand alone against the manufacturer. Allen Stewart, P.C. provides years of experience representing clients against every car manufacturer, including Tesla. We know their tactics and how they may try to minimize or avoid your lemon law claim, and we will fight for you
We Will Hold the Manufacturer Accountable
Whether you’re pursuing a Tesla buyback, or a replacement vehicle, your state’s lemon laws require precise action to ensure you don’t miss your chance to submit your claim. That’s why you need Allen Stewart, P.C., Tesla lemon law lawyers who stand up for your rights. We can get you the compensation you are entitled to.
Please know that manufacturers are not motivated to provide maximum compensation to you. They will try to evade or dismiss your claim. Allen Stewart, P.C. will bring its many years of experience to bear to ensure you receive the justice owed to you. We will hold the manufacturer accountable.
You Pay Nothing Out of Pocket
You do not need to worry about affording a lemon law attorney. Most states require manufacturers to pay claimants’ lemon law attorney fees. The Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act also provides for this.
Find out more about how we can help you get your Tesla buyback or replacement vehicle. Thanks to federal law, our clients pay nothing out of pocket, so contact us now (866-440-2460) for your free consultation or contact us online.
Tesla Lemon Law FAQs
What qualifies my Tesla for a lemon law claim? -
It must still be under the manufacturer’s warranty, and have substantial defects that impact its use, value or safety. Tesla must be given a reasonable number of attempts at repairs (this number of repairs varies according to your state’s lemon laws). You may also check with your lawyer to see if they could pursue a claim using the federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act.
How do I start a lemon law claim for my Tesla? +
Gather all documentation and schedule a consultation with a lemon law attorney. They will guide you through the claim process for a buyback or other compensation. Tesla gets the opportunity to try and fix the problem. The number of repair attempts is regulated by your state’s lemon laws
Can lemon laws cover issues that arise after the warranty has expired? +
How that works is that the issue usually must arise during the warranty period, and could still be covered then, after the warranty expires. Consult your lemon law attorney for details on statutes of limitations, implied warranties, and other provisions applicable to your specific situation.
How long is the lemon law claim process for Tesla vehicles? +
It can take anywhere from a few weeks to several months. Working with a lemon law attorney may shorten the process; with some resolutions coming in approximately two months.
What compensation can I expect from a successful claim? +
You may be able to get a buyback, or a comparable replacement vehicle. Your lemon law attorney will work with you to present your claim to Tesla and discuss potential compensation options.
How to Know if Your Tesla is a Lemon +
Your vehicle must exhibit a substantial defect that severely impacts its use, value or safety, and Tesla has failed to repair it after your state’s number of required repair attempts. These defects can vary, from battery issues, engine problems, electrical malfunctions and many more problems.
Is Your Tesla Eligible for a Lemon Law Buyback? +
This will depend on the problems your vehicle is having and your state lemon laws. Your car must have a substantial defect that severely affects its use, value or safety. The vehicle must not be repairable after the allowed number of repair attempts (per your state lemon laws). A lemon law attorney can review your claim to determine if your Tesla is eligible for a buyback.
Common Tesla Models That Are Classified As Lemons +
Model 3 and Model Y get many lemon law claims due to poor build quality issues, paint defects and software glitches that cause hood latches to open, creating safety problems.
What constitutes a Tesla lemon under the law? +
The main qualifying points are: the Tesla must exhibit a substantial defect or defects that affect its use, value, or safety; and the defects are still present despite a reasonable number of repair attempts by Tesla (the repair attempts are specified by each state’s lemon laws).
What are the potential outcomes of a Tesla lemon law claim? +
You may receive a Tesla buyback, a replacement vehicle, or in some cases, a cash settlement. Your attorney will go over the potential compensation options with you, according to your state’s lemon law and federal law, should that be applicable.
How does Tesla handle lemon law claims? +
Tesla will attempt to fix the vehicle and is allowed several attempts (check your state’s lemon laws for the specific number). Tesla may arrange a buyback, and also it is possible to go through arbitration or have your attorney file a lemon law claim to gain compensation.
What should I do if my Tesla has repeated issues? +
There are specific things you can do before seeking to file a lemon law claim, and since Tesla is allowed opportunities under each state’s lemon laws to fix issues, you can follow these steps to try and resolve the problem:
- Tesla offers their app and In-Car Bug Reporting. Make reports via these to begin your correspondence with Tesla.
- Tesla customer support is available at (877) 798-3752.
- If these steps are unsuccessful, schedule a service center visit to have Tesla attempt a repair.
Can I file a lemon law claim if my Tesla is used? +
You potentially can. Each situation is different; check with a lemon law attorney for information on how your warranty, plus state and federal laws, could affect your specific claim.