Dealing with a defective car can quickly turn into a headache for any vehicle owner under ordinary consumer protection laws. Lemon laws offer you a practical lifeline to escape a cycle of dealership repair visits, time lost, and mounting expenses. A lemon law attorney will consider multiple factors when advising their client between pushing for a cash buyback or demanding a vehicle replacement. Determining which strategy works best requires a careful balance of several moving parts. It relies on the client’s personal goals, how the manufacturer is responding, and building the case with solid evidence.
Before a decision is made on choosing between a replacement vehicle and a buyback, the attorney will determine if your vehicle qualifies as a lemon under state law. We’ll show how the attorney does that, and then we will explore strategies that help lawyers guide their clients toward the best possible outcome.
The Lemon Law Definition of a Substantial Defect
A lemon law attorney is guided by a state’s laws that define what a substantial defect is. The lemon law definition of a substantial defect is one that severely impacts the vehicle’s use, value, or safety. The manufacturer is allotted a set number of repair attempts (usually 3–4) to try to fix the problem. If it cannot or will not, this unfixable substantial defect can often be pursued as a lemon law claim. In some states, after the manufacturer is notified of the claim, it gets one last opportunity to fix the vehicle. The lemon law attorney, once the vehicle is classified as a lemon, will begin the process of proactively dealing with the manufacturer (who may delay, deny, or minimize the claim). Your attorney will protect your right to receive compensation—a buyback or replacement vehicle.
For more information on arbitration and other frequently asked Breach of Warranty questions, click here.
What’s the Difference Between Buyback and Replacement Vehicle Compensation?
1) With a buyback, the manufacturer agrees to take back the defective car and provide a refund. Everything you paid is totaled, including the purchase price, taxes, registration fees, and finance charges during this financial calculation. From that grand total, the manufacturer then subtracts an offset fee based on how many miles were driven before the first repair. Your attorney can explain the offset fee calculation so you will know what to expect.
2) If you choose a replacement vehicle, the manufacturer provides a brand-new, identical vehicle instead of issuing a refund. This option is appealing for many owners because it lets them keep the exact car model they want without starting from scratch. Again, discuss the offset fee with your attorney, as you will owe that to the manufacturer. (Note that some states may waive the offset fee in replacement vehicle scenarios.)
Image Source: Unsplash
How Client Priorities and Market Conditions Influence Choice of Compensation
A lemon law lawyer will take into account what you want for compensation and note that when you first meet for a free consultation (866-440-2460). For some people, the emotional toll of driving an unreliable car creates an urgent need to cut all ties with that specific auto brand, making a buyback the right choice for them. Others want to keep their loan and get another similar car that offers all the features they loved, without the substantial defect ruining the experience. A lawyer can build a strategy that delivers what you need by matching legal tactics directly with these personal motivations.
Outside market forces play a role in shaping what a client may prefer for compensation. A cash buyback might leave a person without enough money to purchase an equivalent vehicle in a high-inflation environment. A replacement vehicle acts as a shield against rising automotive costs, and it allows you to completely bypass current dealership price hikes by going with a duplicate (or near-duplicate) of the original vehicle.
What Happens If You Choose a Buyback?
A lawyer focuses on running the numbers for a potential buyback in the opening days of a new case. If you win your case and receive a buyback, the manufacturer divides the payout, sending you a check for your down payment and monthly equity after paying off your lender. In a successful buyback, the automaker often has to pay back towing, rental car, and registration fees on top of the purchase price.
With a buyback, often the manufacturer goes through a rigid review process inside its legal department. Manufacturers’ legal teams may use stalling tactics during the exchange of case evidence to delay these payouts. A skilled lemon law lawyer can break down a manufacturer’s excuses for holding up the buyback by providing organized proof of the defect, plus evidence of every single monthly payment made.
Lemon laws are confusing. Read our guide to the lemon law complaint process.
What to Expect if You Choose a Vehicle Replacement
Some logistical headaches can crop up during replacement negotiations. Finding an exact match for your specific trim level or color can be challenging within the manufacturer’s current inventory. Even with these potential challenges, a replacement vehicle can help you keep your original loan intact so you can keep your current interest rate locked in. Plus, you’ll maintain your loan equity, and there’s no need for additional credit checks. There will be no additional financing costs for receiving the replacement vehicle.
How the Attorney’s Skill and Experience Can Help You Get the Compensation You Want
The attorney will pursue the option that fits your desired outcome and protects you against manufacturer tactics, such as avoiding the claim, minimizing it, or even blaming you for causing the defect. Through careful structuring of the claim via review of the vehicle warranty, repair records, and other key sources of evidence (internal manufacturer/dealer communications from Technical Service Bulletins; documentation of the defect—written, photographic, video, and other evidence that you supply; and expert testimony), the lemon law attorney will aggressively push for the compensation that you want and are entitled to under state law.
In addition to state laws, the lemon law attorney can also bring to bear federal law protections via the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act. Please note:
“The Act also prohibits these companies from disclaiming or modifying implied warranties with their written ones. This means consumers are always entitled to the basic protections of “implied warranties of merchantability;” that a good sold must do what that good is supposed to. For example: a new car should operate and convey passengers and cargo from one place to another safely. A car that cannot do this does not conform to the implied warranty of merchantability.”
Key point: Most lemon law cases don’t go to court. They are settled, and the negotiation skills of an experienced lemon law attorney can stand you in good stead. Manufacturers usually don’t want to go to court due to the publicity and expense, and it might turn out that the decision would go adversely for them, where they could end up paying more to the consumer than they would in a settlement. Sometimes manufacturers try to offer a quick deal, and that may not be nearly what you could get with a buyback or replacement. A lemon law attorney anticipates these manufacturer tactics and focuses on protecting your rights.
Trust Allen Stewart, P.C. for Expert Lemon Law Representation
A lemon law attorney looks at both financial numbers and human emotions in the final assessment of which type of compensation will be pursued. A buyback is the most dependable strategy if you need quick cash and a total break from a frustrating brand. If you want to save your current financing terms and protect yourself from market inflation, a vehicle replacement can be the right choice. A lemon law lawyer determines the compensation that you want, then pursues the claim to prove the vehicle’s substantial defect.
Even with all the variables we have discussed, you may be wondering if you need a lawyer. Please know that the manufacturer will certainly use its legal team to defend its position. It is vital to have our top attorneys protecting your rights. Allen Stewart, P.C.’s lemon law lawyers are recognized experts, having won many cases across the country.
Note:State lemon laws and federal law require the manufacturer to pay your legal fees when you win your case, so you do not have to pay us to represent you.
To have the best opportunity to gain either a buyback or a replacement vehicle, we encourage you to take advantage of our free consultation. Present your evidence to our attorneys. If your claim is valid, we can discuss next steps and how we can represent you. Contact Allen Stewart, P.C. now (866-440-2460) or schedule your free consultation online.